Whole of market, restricted or tied: what the labels mean and what to ask before you hand over any documents
Week three of a purchase and the phone rings. It is a buyer, polite but clearly worn down. Her broker has not answered an email for ten days, the seller’s agent wants a date for the mortgage offer, and she has no idea which lender is holding her paperwork. Can we take the case over?
Usually we can. It is a messy job, though, and nearly always avoidable. The trouble tends to start in the first five minutes, when she picked the broker.
So this is what I would check if I were hiring one myself, in roughly the order I would check it.
The Job Is Choosing the Lender
People think of a broker as a form-filler. Forms are the easy bit. What you are really paying for is a decision about which lender gets your application, because that decision settles whether you are accepted and what it costs.
Put the same payslips in front of two lenders and the loan amounts can differ by tens of thousands of pounds. Pick the wrong one and you collect a declined application and possibly a mark on your credit file. No rate discount repairs that.
Three Labels Worth Knowing
Go into a bank and ask for mortgage advice and you get a tied adviser. One lender’s products, nobody else’s. Fair enough, they work for the bank.
A restricted adviser sits in the middle. The firm has a panel, perhaps half a dozen lenders, picked by the firm or the network above it. You see those and nothing outside them.
Whole of market means the broker can approach any lender that takes cases through brokers. Notice the wording, because it hides a limit. A few lenders only lend direct. Only the lender itself can sell you one of those, and a broker who claims to cover every lender in the country is stretching it.
You will also meet the word independent, plastered across half the websites in this trade. For mortgage advice it is loose. Firms use it however suits them. Ring and ask a blunt question instead: how many lenders can you place me with, and which ones are closed to you?
Broker or Adviser?
Same job, as far as most people are concerned, and that is fair enough day to day. If you want it exact, the broker is the firm and the adviser is the person talking to you.
What matters is whose products that person is allowed to recommend. A bank adviser is tied. At a broker firm it varies, so ask in the first minute.
So Who Is the Best Mortgage Broker?
Lots of people type that into Google. Nobody can give you a league table, and I would be wary of any firm claiming a place at the top of one.
A broker who is brilliant for a first-time buyer on a steady salary with a 10% deposit may be hopeless for a landlord holding six properties in a limited company. Different animals. A plain purchase has dozens of competent options.
A company director with two years of accounts, a buyer who missed a payment last spring, someone buying a former council flat above a chip shop: these need a firm that sees such cases every week and can name lenders for them without checking.
How Brokers Get Paid
Three ways. The client pays nothing and the lender pays the broker when the mortgage completes. The client pays a fee and the broker also keeps the lender payment. Or the client pays a fee and that is the lot. None of these is dodgy, and none is automatically the cheapest once everything is added up.
For us: the first conversation is free. The lender normally pays us a procuration fee when your mortgage completes, and in some cases we also charge a broker fee. If one applies you will see the amount in writing before you decide anything.
A product switch on your current mortgage is priced separately, and the product switch guarantee page explains what it costs and when we waive it.
Whoever you speak to, ask three things about money. When is any fee due? Do I get it back if the mortgage falls through? Does the lender payment affect which lender you recommend? A decent broker answers in seconds. Hesitation tells you something.
Before You Send a Single Payslip
Start with the Financial Conduct Authority register. Anyone can search it, free of charge.
Type in the firm name and check the address and status against the firm’s own website. The entry should say authorised, and the permissions should include advising on regulated mortgage contracts.
(Some firms work under a bigger network as appointed representatives. The register shows that too.)

Then pick up the phone. How many lenders can the adviser reach? High street banks, building societies, specialist lenders?
I do not need a list of names. I am listening to see whether they have dealt with a case like mine. A firm that lives on simple residential purchases will say so, and that is useful to know.
Regulated firms also hand new clients a short disclosure document at the outset. It lays out which lenders the firm advises on and how it gets paid. Read it before any money moves.
Who will actually run the file? At some firms the voice on the first call disappears and a processor takes over, someone you never speak to. Find out the name, who covers when they are on holiday, and how you will hear about progress. A silent broker in week three has sunk more purchases than any lender I know.
Reviews are worth reading, but read the content. Five stars on its own tells you little.
A review that describes a bad week, a down-valuation say, or a lender pulling out halfway, and how the firm coped, tells you a lot. Twelve near-identical comments posted in the same few days? Draw your own conclusion.
Things That Make Me Wince
A promise of approval, or of a particular rate, before anybody has looked at your finances. The lender decides once it has assessed the application. No broker can guarantee what it will say.
A recommendation inside five minutes with no questions about income, outgoings, credit history or what you plan to do next. If the adviser cannot say why they picked that lender over another, same problem.
An adviser who drops a hint about rounding your income up, or skipping that missed payment from last year. Do not go along with it. That is mortgage fraud, and your name is on the form.
And a firm that will not give its registration details, or whose details do not match the register. Cross it off. No second chances there.
Local, Online or the Estate Agent’s Own
Most brokers now cover the whole country by phone, video and email. Few clients visit an office, and plenty never meet the adviser in person. Whether they know your sort of case counts for much more than a shopfront on your high street.
Some estate agents and developers keep a broker in house or recommend a partner firm. It saves you a job, but it can also mean a short lender panel and a referral payment back to the agent. Put the same questions to that broker as to any other. Nothing obliges you to use the broker the seller suggests.
Where a Specialist Earns the Fee
Clean purchase, good deposit, steady salary: a bank adviser and a broker may end up in much the same place. Awkward cases are where they split.
Take a self-employed designer with two years of accounts and a healthy deposit. One lender averages her profit across both years and offers a modest loan. Another looks at the latest year alone and offers a good deal more.
A tied adviser can only try her with the first. A whole of market broker can start with the second. Landlords buying through a limited company, people with past credit problems and buyers of unusual properties meet the same split.
Our pages on buy-to-let mortgages, self-employed mortgages and bad credit mortgages cover these routes in detail, and our post on how brokers place difficult cases follows one from start to finish.
What You Get From Us
We are whole of market. Before anything goes near a lender, we tell you who is likely to say yes, what rate and fees to expect and where the case might snag. If your own bank has the best deal, we will say so and you can take it.
You are welcome to speak to one of our mortgage brokers before you apply. No commitment. You should come away knowing what is realistic.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I find a good mortgage broker?
Check the firm on the Financial Conduct Authority register first.
Then ring two or three and put the same questions to each: how many lenders can you place me with, how are you paid, and have you done a case like mine? Half an hour on the phone beats a whole evening of reading reviews.
Is it better to use a mortgage broker or go direct to my bank?
On a simple purchase with a big deposit your bank may match a broker on rate, and an honest broker will tell you so.
Brokers earn their keep on awkward cases, or when you want many lenders compared before you commit. Going direct means seeing one lender’s range, which suits you only if that lender happens to fit.
What is the difference between a mortgage broker and a mortgage adviser?
In everyday talk, nothing.
Strictly, the broker is the firm and the adviser is the individual who advises you. The thing to find out is how wide a range that individual can recommend from: one lender for a tied adviser, a bigger panel for a whole of market broker.
How much does a mortgage broker cost?
It depends on the firm.
Some charge clients nothing and are paid by the lender, some add a fee on top of the lender payment, and a few charge a fee only. With us the first conversation is free, and if a fee applies you will have the amount in writing before you commit.
What does whole of market mean?
The broker can approach any lender that takes applications through brokers.
A handful of lenders sell only direct, and a broker cannot reach them. So the claim covers the broker market, not every lender in the country.
How do I check a mortgage broker is regulated?
Search for the firm on the Financial Conduct Authority register.
Make sure the name and address match the website, the status says authorised and the permissions include advising on regulated mortgage contracts. If something does not add up, ask the firm about it before you send any documents.
Can I use more than one mortgage broker at the same time?
I would not.
Two brokers can send the same case to the same lender, which then sees two applications in your name. That slows both down and muddles who holds your documents. Choose one, give them a fair run, and change firms if the service falls short.

Speak to a Mortgage Broker Who Will Tell You Where You Stand
Call us or send your details if you want a straight view on which lenders suit your case before you apply. We will say what is realistic, what it costs and what we would do in your position.
UK Mortgage Broker is a whole-of-market broker helping clients throughout the UK and globally to secure funding on UK property. We are directly authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.
Call: +44 1628 969 500 Email: info@uk-mortgagebroker.co.uk
Related Pages
- Process of Getting a Residential Mortgage – what happens at each stage between choosing a broker and getting the keys.
- Mortgage Agreement in Principle Explained – what an agreement in principle tells you and what it does not.
- Broker-Only Mortgage Rates – why some lenders only offer their best deals through brokers.
- Mortgage Affordability UK – how lenders work out what you can borrow from income, commitments and stress tests.
- First-Time Buyer Mortgages – whole-of-market advice for buying your first home.
